Top 5 Roofing Companies in South Bend, Indiana: Comprehensive Review
South Bend homeowners have access to several experienced roofing contractors, each with distinct specialties and service approaches. This detailed analysis examines five leading companies based on their websites, customer feedback, industry certifications, and actual project experiences to help you make an informed decision.
Company Profiles
A&M Home Services
Website: https://www.roofsandbasements.com
Key Service: Full-spectrum exterior remodeling with GAF Master-Elite roofing certification
A&M Home Services operates as a comprehensive home services provider serving Northern Indiana and Southern Michigan, with established offices in both Plymouth and South Bend. As a GAF Master-Elite® Contractor, they offer lifetime warranties on all roofing installations and maintain BBB A+ accreditation. The company specializes in roofing, gutter replacement, waterproofing, siding, and other exterior services for both residential and commercial properties.
Customer Reviews:
“Very good job. Very professional, courteous, and punctual. New roof looks great. Good cleanup.” – Nancy L., South Bend
“I used A&M Home Services for roofing. We got a new roof on. He did gutter work too. They did a wonderful job. Their response was really good on that job.” – Ronald O., South Bend
Best Fit For: Property owners seeking bundled exterior services under one contractor, those who value manufacturer certifications and comprehensive warranties, and customers preferring established companies with formal accreditation.
Not Ideal For: Budget-conscious homeowners focused solely on roofing, those preferring smaller boutique contractors, or customers wanting immediate response times during peak seasons.
South Bend Roofing
Website: https://southbendroofing.com
Key Service: Premium residential and commercial roofing with over 100 years of industry experience
South Bend Roofing stands as the area’s longest-established roofing company, founded in 1914 and BBB-accredited since 2014 with an A+ rating. They offer comprehensive roofing, siding, windows, and gutters for both residential and commercial applications. The company emphasizes premium materials, industry-leading warranties, and energy-efficient solutions, including specialized Durolast commercial roofing systems.
Customer Reviews:
“They do good work, and they’re fair and honest in their business practices. The owner remembers every tear off and install for the last 35 years off the top of his head any given day of the week… it’s rare.” – Kyle L., former employee
“After the last big snow storm I developed an ice dam. Water pouring down a wall and through the ceiling. I called SB Roofing and they came out same day, TWICE to break up 2 separate problem areas. Estimate was lower than I expected. Repairs were done. I couldn’t be happier!” – Kevin R., South Bend
Best Fit For: Customers prioritizing longevity and proven track record, commercial property owners, those wanting premium materials with extended warranties, and homeowners seeking energy-efficient roofing solutions.
Not Ideal For: Budget-focused projects, customers needing rapid turnaround times, or those preferring more modern communication methods and project tracking.
Relentless Roofing
Website: https://relentlessroofingco.com
Key Service: Insurance claims expertise and storm damage restoration with 5-star customer service focus
Relentless Roofing Co. specializes in residential and commercial roofing with particular expertise in insurance claims and storm damage restoration. The company has successfully secured nearly $2,000,000 in uncompensated insurance funds for over 1,000 Michiana homeowners. They focus exclusively on metal and shingle roofing (98% of their work) and emphasize constant communication throughout projects.
Customer Reviews:
“Tj and his crew were great. Very professional and made the replacement process so easy. He walked me through every step so that I was informed and confident when speaking with my agent. They ended up fully covering the replacement!” – Bou Blosser
“We were pleasantly surprised by the constant communication during the project. The quality of the work was flawless. The crew worked tirelessly to get the job done despite tough weather conditions.” – John Sheetz
Best Fit For: Homeowners dealing with insurance claims after storm damage, customers who value detailed communication and project transparency, and those seeking specialized expertise in metal and shingle roofing.
Not Ideal For: Price-sensitive customers seeking the lowest bid, those preferring hands-off project management, or homeowners needing specialty roofing materials beyond metal and shingles.
No Limit Roofing
Website: https://nolimitroofingin.com
Key Service: Comprehensive roofing services with GAF certification and 50+ year lifetime systems
No Limit Roofing, established in 2010, serves the Greater South Bend-Elkhart region as a fully licensed, insured, and bonded roofing specialist. Owner Jonathan Smith brings over 25 years of experience and personally supervises all jobs. The company holds over 300 industry certifications and offers lifetime roofing systems lasting 50+ years. They handle all roofing types, including asphalt, composite shingles, metal, wood shakes, tile, and various flat roof systems.
Customer Reviews:
“They were prompt, accurate, and professional. I will definitely recommend them for your roofing needs.” – K Hall, South Bend
“Jon gave us stellar customer service, and I didn’t have to worry!! Highly recommend!!” – L Bauer, South Bend
Best Fit For: Customers seeking comprehensive roofing expertise across multiple material types, those wanting owner-supervised projects, and homeowners interested in long-term roofing solutions with extended warranties.
Not Ideal For: Customers preferring large corporate structures, those seeking the absolute lowest pricing, or homeowners wanting boutique-level personal attention throughout the process.
Asscher Roofing
Website: https://asscherroofing.com
Key Service: Local roofing, fascia, gutters, and siding with GAF Certified Plus status
Asscher Roofing is a locally owned company with over 24 years in business, specializing in roofing, fascia, gutters, siding, and soffit services for residential and commercial properties. The company holds GAF Certified Plus status, enabling them to offer enhanced System Plus® Limited Warranty and Silver Pledge™ Limited Warranty on qualifying roof systems. They emphasize their local community connections and understanding of regional roofing needs.
Customer Reviews:
“Asscher Roofing Company replaced my roof as well as some needed repairs. I am extremely satisfied with their speed and quality work. I would highly recommend them.” – GAF review
“They did a great job on some roof repairs and new gutters. I highly recommend. The price was decent.” – Yelp review
Best Fit For: Homeowners preferring locally owned businesses with community ties, customers seeking GAF-certified contractors with enhanced warranty options, and those wanting a contractor specializing in complete exterior services.
Not Ideal For: Large commercial projects requiring extensive resources, customers seeking the most competitive pricing, or those preferring companies with an extensive online presence.
Comparative Analysis
| Company | Years Operating | BBB Rating | Primary Certification | Warranty Highlight | Best For |
| A&M Home Services | 14 | A+ (Accredited) | GAF Master-Elite | Lifetime on GAF systems | Multi-trade projects |
| South Bend Roofing | 111 | A+ (Accredited) | Industry certifications | 30-year coverage | Premium materials/commercial |
| Relentless Roofing | ~10 | Not listed | Metal & shingle specialists | Not specified | Insurance claims |
| No Limit Roofing | 15 | A (Not accredited) | GAF Factory-Certified | Lifetime systems (50+ years) | Comprehensive expertise |
| Asscher Roofing | 24+ | Not rated | GAF Certified Plus | System Plus Limited | Local community focus |
Key Considerations for Selection
For Insurance Claims: Relentless Roofing offers the most specialized insurance claim assistance, having secured nearly $2 million for local homeowners.
For Established Reputation: South Bend Roofing’s 111-year history and BBB A+ accreditation provide maximum credibility.
For Comprehensive Services: A&M Home Services excels at bundling roofing with other exterior projects under unified warranties.
For Technical Expertise: No Limit Roofing’s 300+ certifications and multi-material capabilities suit complex projects.
For Local Connection: Asscher Roofing’s 24+ year local presence and community focus appeal to homeowners preferring neighborhood contractors.
Each company serves different customer priorities, from premium materials and established reputation to insurance expertise and comprehensive certifications. Match your specific needs—budget, timeline, project scope, and service preferences—to the contractor whose strengths align with your requirements for the best roofing experience in South Bend.
