Reviewed: Top 6 Roofing Companies in Mishawaka, Indiana

If you’re looking for a roofing company in Mishawaka, you’ll want to compare a few before you decide. You should. We’re Better Way Roofing, and we’d rather you put our quote next to one or two others than just take our word for it. So we’ve reviewed six roofing companies serving Mishawaka the same way we’d want to be reviewed: fairly, with the details that actually matter, and with every figure checked against the company’s own website, Google, the BBB, or the shingle manufacturer.

Horner Roofing & Siding

hornerroofingandsiding.com

Key Service: Storm damage roofing and siding, with the insurance claim handled for you

What Stands Out:
Horner is the only company in this review headquartered in the middle of Mishawaka, on Union Street. Micah and Jessica Horner started it in 2016 as a one-man operation, and it now runs offices in Fort Wayne and Portage, Michigan too. Storm damage is the heart of the business: a named team member works directly with your insurance adjuster and handles supplements, and that theme runs through review after review. Their site shows CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster and IKO RoofPro credentials, and they also do commercial TPO, EPDM and silicone coatings. They hold an A+ BBB rating, accredited since 2017, and average 4.9 stars across more than 270 reviews.

"We brought in Horner Roofing on short notice after another contractor couldn't do the job. They communicated quickly and clearly, showed up on time, and got the work done efficiently."Rob C.

"We had storm damage to our house and garage. Marlin was super helpful with working with the insurance company and answering all our questions."Marianne A.

Fit For:

• Homeowners with hail or wind damage who want someone to deal with the insurance company for them
• Buyers who want roof, siding, gutters and windows from one contractor
• Churches and small commercial buildings that need a flat roof or a silicone coating

Not Ideal For:

• Homeowners who want to see a workmanship warranty term before they sign. Horner’s website doesn’t publish one, so ask for it in writing.
• Anyone who wants the owner on every job. With offices in three towns, day-to-day contact is mostly with their project staff and general contractors.

Rooftech Construction

rooftechconstruction.com

Key Service: GAF Master Elite roof replacement and repair, with detailed inspection reports

What Stands Out:
Rooftech is based in South Bend, on Clairmont Drive, and has served Mishawaka since 2007. The numbers speak for themselves: 489 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0, the most of any single location in this review. They are a GAF Master Elite contractor (we checked GAF’s own directory), which lets them offer GAF’s top Golden Pledge warranty, and they advertise their own “Lifetime No Leak Guarantee”. Reviewers often mention how organized their inspection reports are. They hold an A+ BBB rating, accredited since 2019, and are licensed in both Indiana and Michigan.

"Rooftech installed our roof 4 years ago. Their initial service and any routine follow-ups due to crazy weather has been top notch. Response time is fantastic."Lora R.

"The team handled tricky steep angles with ease, and the results look fantastic. Great price and great service!"William C.

Fit For:

• Buyers who want a GAF Master Elite installer and access to the GAF Golden Pledge warranty
• Homeowners who weigh review volume heavily. Nearly 500 five-star reviews is a lot of happy customers.
• Repairs that cross trades: roof, chimney, gutters and siding

Not Ideal For:

• Metal roofing. Rooftech doesn’t advertise it.
• Flat or low-slope commercial roofs where you want a named membrane system. Their commercial page doesn’t specify one.
• Buyers who want a workmanship warranty stated in years. Ask exactly what the “Lifetime No Leak Guarantee” covers.

Gean Roofing

geanroofing.com

Key Service: Owens Corning Platinum Preferred roof replacement, from a family business founded in 1991

What Stands Out:
Jason Gean started Gean Roofing in 1991, and it is still locally owned and family operated, from North Liberty with a second office in Niles, Michigan. They hold Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status, the top tier of the Owens Corning contractor program (confirmed in Owens Corning’s directory), and describe themselves as the longest-standing Platinum Preferred contractor in the Midwest. They are refreshingly upfront on price: their own website says “We are not the cheapest contractor.” Several recent reviews describe being told their roof had years left in it. They average 4.8 stars from 215 Google reviews.

"Cooper (Salesman) listened to my needs as my dormer had been leaking for years. He communicated that through to Kurtis (Foreman) and then he communicated to his crew of the issue."Greg M.

"Gean Roofing is a company that represents honesty and integrity and is a pleasure to do business with."Kate K.

Fit For:

• Homeowners who want an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred installer and the strongest Owens Corning warranties
• Anyone who wants a straight answer on repair versus replacement
• Projects that pair a new roof with seamless gutters or attic insulation

Not Ideal For:

• Flat or low-slope roofs. Gean is residential-led, and a recent reviewer says they couldn’t take on a flat roof job.
• Siding or a full exterior package. They don’t offer siding.
• Buyers chasing the lowest bid. By their own account, they aren’t it.

A&M Home Services

roofsandbasements.com

Key Service: GAF Master Elite roofing alongside siding, windows, gutters and basement waterproofing

What Stands Out:
A&M is one of the largest home improvement contractors in Northern Indiana, with six offices including one on Delaware Street in Mishawaka and a team of more than 50. Owner Jared McQueen founded the company in 2011. They hold GAF Master Elite status and the GAF Triple Excellence Award. Roofing is only half the story: as the web address suggests, basements, crawl spaces and foundation repair are a big part of what they do. Their Mishawaka location shows 5.0 stars from 145 Google reviews, and the company as a whole has close to 1,200. The main company profile holds an A+ BBB rating, accredited since 2014.

"I needed a roof repair to be done quickly, and these guys rearranged their schedule to fit me in before a big snowstorm."David H.

"Great experience working with A&M. I found them to be very knowledgeable, trustworthy and on schedule. I'd highly recommend them!"Brian S.

Fit For:

• Homeowners bundling several jobs (roof, siding, windows, gutters, a wet basement) with one company
• Buyers who want a GAF Master Elite contractor and GAF’s top warranty tiers
• Customers who value a large, established firm with deep resources

Not Ideal For:

• Budget shoppers. Six offices and top-tier GAF systems usually mean mid-to-upper pricing.
• Anyone who wants a roofing specialist with the owner on site. A&M is a multi-trade company, and roofing shares the spotlight with basement work.
• Homeowners who want one clear warranty figure. A&M describes its warranties differently on different pages of its site, so ask for the exact terms in writing.

Sherriff Goslin Roofing

sherriffgoslin.com

Key Service: Proprietary Art-Loc interlocking shingles with a 10-year free service guarantee

What Stands Out:
Sherriff Goslin’s “South Bend” branch is actually in Mishawaka, on McKinley Highway, and it has served this area since 1933. The company itself dates to 1906 in Battle Creek, Michigan, is still run by the founding families, and has 17 branches across Michigan, Indiana and Ohio and more than 250,000 roofs behind it. Their signature product is Art-Loc, a patented interlocking diamond-pattern shingle made exclusively for Sherriff Goslin, so you can’t get it from anyone else. Every customer gets a dedicated project manager. They also cover farm buildings, churches and commercial flat roofs. The branch holds an A+ BBB rating, accredited since 2010.

"Dave and Bobby came out very promptly and addressed my issue and were able to explain it so that it was easily understood."Maria G.

"I had a great experience with Bobby Classon with Sherriff Goslin. He was prompt, courteous and very knowledgeable."Russ S.

Fit For:

• Homeowners who want the Art-Loc shingle, which no other contractor offers
• Buyers who value a long track record and a dedicated project manager on every job
• Owners of farm buildings, churches or commercial property who want one roofer for all of it

Not Ideal For:

• Homeowners who put follow-up communication first. The branch’s BBB profile shows six complaints closed in the last three years, and some reviews mention slow contact after the visit.
• Anyone who wants a locally owned, owner-on-site contractor. This is a 17-branch regional company run from Battle Creek.
• Buyers set on Owens Corning or GAF systems. Sherriff Goslin installs Atlas-made shingles, and its headline cover is a 10-year service guarantee.

No Limit Roofing

nolimitroofingin.com

Key Service: Owner-supervised residential roofing, including tear-offs, overlays and unusual roof types

What Stands Out:
No Limit Roofing is based on Clover Road in Mishawaka. Owner Jonathan Smith has more than 25 years in the trade and, according to the company, supervises every job himself, and reviewers name “Jon” again and again. The company says it has served the area since 2010 (the current business was registered in 2023). They work on a wider range of roof types than most: asphalt, metal, wood shake, tile, and several flat-roof membranes, and they offer both full tear-offs and overlays. They describe themselves as a GAF factory-certified contractor. They average 4.9 stars from 120 Google reviews and hold an A+ BBB rating (not accredited).

"Our home had three layers of old roofing (when code only allows two), and their team handled the full tear-off and replacement seamlessly."Samantha C.

"They went above and beyond to protect our stuff and our windows and had a very thorough clean up process."Brady C.

Fit For:

• Homeowners who want the owner personally involved in their job
• Unusual or mixed roofs: tile, wood shake, flat sections, or a house with several old layers to strip
• Budget-flexible projects. Recent reviewers on Google list full-roof prices between $8,000 and $12,000.

Not Ideal For:

• Buyers who want a manufacturer credential they can look up. We couldn’t find No Limit in GAF’s contractor directory, so ask for proof of certification.
• Anyone who wants a stated workmanship warranty. None is published, so get it in writing.
• Homeowners offered an overlay. Roofing over old shingles can hide rotten decking and limit your shingle warranty, so ask how it affects yours before agreeing.

How These Mishawaka Roofing Companies Compare

For full transparency, we have added Better Way Roofing to the bottom of the table and marked it clearly as the publisher of this article. We are not part of the ranked review above. This simply lets you compare us on the same measures.

Choosing the Right Roofer for Your Mishawaka Home

Horner Roofing & Siding is the one to call if a storm has just been through and you want someone to deal with the insurance company for you. They are also the only company here with headquarters in central Mishawaka.

Rooftech Construction has the strongest review record in this list and GAF’s top contractor status. If you want a GAF roof with the Golden Pledge warranty, start here.

Gean Roofing is the pick if you want an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred installer with more than three decades of local history, and an honest answer on whether you need a new roof at all.

A&M Home Services makes sense for bigger projects: a roof, new siding and a wet basement handled by one company.

Sherriff Goslin offers something nobody else can, the Art-Loc shingle, backed by more than 90 years on McKinley Highway. Just ask how follow-up service works before you sign.

No Limit Roofing suits homeowners who want the owner on the job and have an unusual roof, as long as you get the warranty and certification in writing.

Before you sign with anyone, check the permit. Mishawaka handles building permits through the city, not St. Joseph County, and the fee usually runs $40 to $100 depending on the size of the job. A good contractor pulls the permit for you and puts the fee in the quote. You can check with the Mishawaka Building Department at 100 Lincolnway West. For more on comparing contractors, see our questions to ask before hiring a roofing contractor and our guide to understanding roofing warranties.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a permit to replace my roof in Mishawaka?

Yes. Mishawaka handles building permits through the city Building Department rather than St. Joseph County. The fee usually runs $40 to $100 depending on the size of the job. A good roofing contractor pulls the permit for you and includes the fee in your quote.

How do I check a Mishawaka roofing contractor's credentials?

Indiana has no statewide roofing license, so check for yourself. Look the company up in the shingle manufacturer's own contractor directory, find the BBB profile for the branch you're dealing with, and ask for proof of liability insurance and workers' compensation before you sign.

Which Mishawaka roofing companies are Owens Corning or GAF certified?

Of the six we reviewed, Gean Roofing is Owens Corning Platinum Preferred, and Rooftech Construction and A&M Home Services are GAF Master Elite, all confirmed in the manufacturers' directories. Certifications are renewed regularly, so check the current status before you sign.

Should I choose a Mishawaka-based roofer or a regional roofing company?

Both can do good work. A Mishawaka-based company like Horner or No Limit is close by and often more personal. Regional firms like A&M or Sherriff Goslin bring more staff and resources. Choose on credentials, a written warranty and how they treat you during the quote.

Last updated: October 2, 2026